How To Choose The Best Yarn for Crochet? The Ultimate Guide by Mermaidcat (2023)

Best Crochet Yarn Guide
Find out how you choose the best yarn for crochet in this Ultimate guide, exploring yarn weight, fiber content, hook size tips and more!

Unlock Your Crochet Potential: The Must-Knows of Crochet and Yarn

Greetings And A Warm Welcome To Mermaidcat Designs, Where Crochet Is Not Just A Hobby, But A Passion.

Are you looking for the best yarn for crochet? With countless of hours of yarn on the hook, you’ll learn things that took me years to find out.

I’m Stacey, Founder of Mermaidcat Designs. I’ve been lucky enough to see my creations brought to life by talented crafters in 60+ countries all over the world. It brings me great joy to teach others and help crocheters like you along their crochet path.

Stacey of Mermaidcat Designs - Founder and Designer

We’ll go over some basic info for beginners but this guide is a great reference for all experience levels. Feel free to book mark it and return for a quick reference.

When selecting the best yarn for crochet, several considerations must be taken into account. Understanding these concepts will not only improve your results but also make a more enjoyable and comfortable crocheting journey.

Today’s Focus: What Is The Best Yarn For Crochet?

You’ll get answers to:

  • How do I choose the best crochet yarn for my project?
  • How does yarn weight affect my crochet project?
  • What type of yarn is best for crochet garments like sweaters and dresses?
  • How does yarn fiber content impact the final outcome of a crochet project?
  • What are the top crochet yarn brands of 2023?

Lastly, we’ll explore other factors such as color and texture preferences, price point considerations, and care instructions when selecting the perfect yarn for your crochet endeavors. By the end of this overview, you’ll be able to make a yarn choice you’re happy with for your next project. 

Welcome To The Yarn Guide Banner

Table of Contents:

I’ve included links to crochet yarn and accessories I use and love. As an affiliate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. Happy Hooking. -Stacey



1. Yarn Weight

When starting a crochet project, it’s essential to choose the right yarn weight for your creations. The term “yarn weight” refers to the thickness of the yarn strand and is crucial in determining how your finished project will look and feel. In this section, we’ll explore different yarn weights available for crochet projects, tips on choosing the right one for you, and working with various weights.

a. What is Yarn Weight?

Yarn weight categories range from super fine (such as lace) to jumbo (perfect for those chunky blankets). Each category has its own set of recommended gauge ranges, which are guidelines that help ensure your final product comes out just as you envisioned it. Here’s a quick rundown of common yarn weights:

  • Lace: Ideal for delicate shawls or doilies.
  • Fingering/Sock: Perfect for lightweight socks or baby clothes.
  • Sport: Great choice for light sweaters or baby blankets.
  • Worsted/Aran: A versatile option suitable for most crochet projects like scarves, hats, and afghans.
  • Bulky/Chunky: Best suited for warm winter accessories such as cozy cowls or oversized throws.
  • Jumbo/Roving: Ideal when you want to create large-scale items quickly using big hooks. 

b. How to Choose the Right Yarn Weight For Your Project

Selecting an appropriate yarn weight depends on factors like desired texture, stitch definition, drapeability (how well it hangs), and the time you have to complete your project. To help guide your decision, consider these tips:

  1. Check the pattern: Most crochet patterns will specify a recommended yarn weight and hook size for optimal results.
  2. Consider the purpose of your project: For example, if you’re making dishcloths or baby blankets, opt for a worsted weight yarn that’s machine washable and durable.
  3. Think about climate: Lighter-weight yarns are better suited for warm weather garments while heavier weights provide extra warmth in colder months.
Choosing The Right Weight Yarn - Stack of Yarn Balls in Many Colors

c. Tips for Working with Different Yarn Weights

No matter which yarn weight you choose, there are some general guidelines to follow when working on your crochet projects:

  • Gauge matters: Always make a gauge swatch before starting any project. This helps ensure proper sizing and avoids potential disappointment later on. 
  • Tension is key: Maintain consistent tension throughout your work; this can be especially challenging when switching between different yarn weights within one piece. 
  • Mind those edges: When working with finer-weight yarns like lace or fingering, use smaller hooks to create clean edges without gaps or holes. 
  • Patiently persevere: Some yarn fibers may require more effort (and patience) but result in beautiful statement pieces worth the extra time invested. 

Incorporating these tips into your crochet routine will set you up for success regardless of which fabulous fiber makes its way onto your hook. Stay tuned as we dive deeper into other factors that influence your perfect yarn choice, including fiber content and hook size considerations.

Choosing the right yarn for a crochet project necessitates considering its weight as an important factor. Moving on from this, it’s also essential to understand the different fiber contents available in order to make a more informed decision.


Key Takeaway: 

This section furnishes guidance on selecting the suitable yarn weight for a crochet project, considering elements such as aim, tension, expertise level and atmosphere. It also offers advice on working with different yarn weights including mixing them up and being aware of substitutions that may affect the final outcome of your piece.

Crochet Shag Jacket Pattern - Baby - By Mermaidcat Designs - 5 Star Etsy Shop
Crochet Jacket Patter, Baby by Mermaidcat. Learn More →


2. Fiber Content

Understanding the differences between natural and synthetic fibers is crucial for choosing the best crochet yarn for your project. We’ll explore the pros and cons of each type of fiber and help you make an informed decision when selecting your perfect yarn.

a. What is Fiber Content?

Fiber content refers to the materials used in making a particular yarn. Yarns can be made from various sources, including plants (such as cotton), animals (like wool) or even man-made materials (acrylic). Each fiber has its unique characteristics that will affect how it feels, behaves during crocheting, and ultimately looks in your finished project.

b. Natural vs Synthetic Fibers

  • Natural Fibers: These are derived from plant or animal sources like cotton, wool, silk, bamboo or alpaca fibers.
    • Pros: They tend to be soft with excellent drape; they’re breathable and often biodegradable.
    • Cons: They may require more care when washing; some people might have allergies to specific natural fibers such as wool.
  • Synthetic Fibers: Man-made materials like acrylics or polyester fall under this category.
    • Pros: Affordable options that are durable; many are machine washable which makes them great for baby clothes or blankets.
    • Cons: They may not be as breathable, and some can feel less soft compared to natural fibers.

c. Pros and Cons of Different Fibers

Now that we’ve covered the basics of natural vs synthetic fibers, let’s dive deeper into specific fiber types you might encounter when searching for your perfect crochet yarn:

  1. Cotton Yarn: Soft, smooth yarn with excellent stitch definition; ideal for making dishcloths or summer garments.
    • Pros: Breathable, machine washable and holds up well over time.
    • Cons: May lack elasticity which could make it harder to maintain even tension in crochet stitches.
  2. Wool Yarn: Soft, warm and elastic with good stitch definition; ideal for making cozy garments and accessories.
    • Pros: Great for insulation, easy to work with, and can be machine washed (depending on the specific type).
    • Cons: Some people may find wool itchy, and it can be more expensive than other types of yarn.
  3. Acrylic Yarn:Versatile, lightweight and affordable; ideal for making blankets, scarves and hats.
    • Pros: Easy to care for, widely available, and typically more affordable than natural fibers.
    • Cons: May lack the same softness and warmth as natural fibers, and can pill or fuzz over time.
  4. Alpaca Yarn: Soft, silky and warm with a fuzzy texture; ideal for making luxurious garments and accessories.
    • Pros: Lightweight, warm and naturally water-repellent.
    • Cons: Can be more expensive than other types of yarn, and may not be as readily available as other fibers.
  5. Mohair Yarn: Silky and soft with a fluffy texture; ideal for making warm, fuzzy garments and accessories.
    • Pros: Soft, fluffy texture that gives a unique look and feel to projects.
    • Cons: Can shed fibers and may be more difficult to care for than other types of yarn.
  6.  Bamboo Yarn: Silky, smooth and cool to the touch; ideal for making lightweight, breathable garments and accessories.
    • Pros: Breathable, lightweight and eco-friendly.
    • Cons: May lack elasticity, making it harder to maintain tension in crochet stitches.

Fiber content is an important consideration when choosing the best yarn for crochet, as different fibers have their own unique characteristics. Hook size considerations are also essential in order to achieve a successful project; understanding how hook sizes affect your work can help you create beautiful and lasting pieces of art.

Ergonomic Crochet Hooks
The Ergonomic Hook Set I Love. I wish I knew about these years ago.


3. Hook Size Considerations

Now that you have a better comprehension of yarn weight and fiber material, it’s time to delve into the realm of hook sizes. Picking the appropriate crochet hook size is essential for your project’s success. In this section, we’ll investigate the significance of hook size selection for your project’s success, and provide guidance on how to pick the best one as well as tips for working with varying sizes.

a. What is Hook Size?

Crochet hooks come in various sizes to accommodate different yarn weights and create specific stitch tightness or looseness. They are usually labeled with a letter (US system) or number (UK system), as well as their corresponding millimeter measurement (Craft Yarn Council Crochet Hook Chart). For example, an H-8 US-sized crochet hook measures 5mm in diameter.

b. Choosing the Right Hook Size for Your Project

  1. Check the yarn label: Most yarn labels will recommend a specific crochet hook size range that works best with that particular yarn weight. This information can be found alongside other essential details like care instructions and gauge information.
  2. Gauge swatch: If you’re following a pattern, it’s essential to make sure your stitches match up with those specified by the designer (How To Crochet A Gauge Swatch – Interweave Article). Creating a gauge swatch helps ensure your finished project comes out at just the right dimensions.
  3. Tension considerations: Each crocheter has their unique tension when working with yarn. If you tend to crochet tightly, you may need a larger hook size than recommended on the yarn label or pattern. Conversely, if your stitches are typically loose, try using a smaller hook.

c. Tips for Working with Different Hook Sizes

  • Invest in a set: To accommodate various projects and yarn weights, consider investing in a set of crochet hooks. This way, you’ll always have the right size at hand. Here’s the set I use and love. Learn More →
  • Ergonomic handles: Crocheting can be hard on your hands over time. Look for hooks with ergonomic handles that provide better grip and comfort during long crocheting sessions (Ultimate Guide To The Best Crochet Hooks Article).
  • Practice makes perfect: Experimenting with different hook sizes is an excellent way to improve your skills as a crocheter. Experimenting with different tools can help you refine your craft and gain confidence in tackling any project.

Incorporating these tips into your crochet journey will ensure that you’re well-equipped to tackle any project confidently. Remember: choosing the right combination of yarn weight, fiber content, and hook size is essential for bringing your creative vision to life.

Selecting the proper hook size is a crucial component when picking out yarn for your crochet projects. By taking into account the other factors such as color, texture and price point, you can make sure that you choose the best yarn for your project.


Key Takeaway: 

Picking the accurate crochet hook size is essential for a successful endeavor. Crochet hooks come in various sizes to accommodate different yarn weights and create specific stitch tightness or looseness. Tips for working with different hook sizes include investing in a set, looking for ergonomic handles, and experimenting with different tools to improve your skills as a crocheter.

Choosing The Right Weight Yarn - Stack of Yarn Balls in Many Colors


4. Other Factors to Consider When Choosing Yarn

Now that we’ve covered yarn weight, fiber content, and hook size considerations, let’s dive into some other factors you should keep in mind when selecting the perfect yarn for your crochet project. We’ll discuss color and texture choices, price point considerations, and care instructions.

a. Color and Texture Considerations

The color and texture of your yarn can make a significant impact on the final look of your crochet project. While it might be tempting to choose a bold variegated or self-striping yarn because it looks fun in the skein, remember that intricate stitch patterns may get lost in those color changes.

  • Solid colors: Great for showcasing complex stitch patterns or creating timeless pieces.
  • Tonal colors: Provide subtle variations within one hue without overwhelming delicate stitches.
  • Multicolored/variegated/self-striping: Ideal for simple stitch patterns where you want the color transitions to shine through.
  • Fuzzy/textured/novelty yarns: Can add visual interest but may also obscure detailed stitches; best used sparingly as accents or combined with smoother fibers.

b. Price Point Considerations

Your budget will undoubtedly play a role in choosing the right yarn for your project. Keep these tips in mind when considering cost:

  • Avoid sacrificing quality just to save money – poor-quality fibers won’t hold up well over time or feel good against skin if making wearables like scarves or sweaters.
  • Consider shopping sales, clearance sections, or using coupons to get higher-quality yarns at a more affordable price point. Websites like Lion Brand and Knit Picks often have great deals on quality fibers.
  • If you’re working on a large project (like an afghan), consider breaking it up into smaller pieces that use different colors or textures of yarn – this can help spread out the cost while still creating a cohesive final product.

c. Care Instructions

Last but not least, don’t forget to take note of the care instructions for your chosen yarn. If you’re making something that will need frequent washing (such as baby items) or if gifting to someone who may not be familiar with fiber care, opt for easy-care fibers like acrylics and superwash wools. Always include care instructions when giving handmade gifts so recipients know how best to maintain their new treasures.

Note: Some people are sensitive or allergic to certain fibers; always check with gift recipients about any known allergies before starting your project.


Key Takeaway: 

When choosing yarn for crochet, consider color and texture to complement each other. Price point is another factor to keep in mind; there are affordable options available but luxury fibers like cashmere or silk can make a project feel extra special. Lastly, always check care instructions before purchasing to ensure proper care of the finished piece.

Catlantis Crochet Top Pattern By Mermaidcat Designs - Top Rated Etsy Pattern Shop
Catlantis Crochet Crop Top Pattern by Mermaidcat. Learn More →


FAQs in Relation to What is the Best Yarn for Crochet

What is the Best Yarn for Crochet?

The best yarn for crochet depends on your project and personal preferences. However, a versatile option is medium-weight (worsted) acrylic yarn, as it’s easy to work with, affordable, and widely available. Brands like Knit Picks Dishie or Lion Brand Vanna’s Choice are popular choices.

What is the Best Yarn Weight to Learn Crochet?

For beginners learning to crochet, it’s recommended to start with a medium-weight (worsted) yarn. This weight provides a good balance between thickness and manageability while still being easy to see your stitches. Look for brands such as Knit Picks and Lion Brand.

What is the Best Crochet Hook For Beginners?

The best crochet hook for beginners is typically an ergonomic or soft-grip hook in a size H-8 (5 mm) or I-9 (5.5 mm). These sizes are versatile and work well with a variety of yarn weights, making them a great choice for beginners. Find The Set Here →



Choosing the best yarn for crochet depends on several factors, including yarn weight, fiber content, hook size considerations, and other factors such as color and texture preferences. When selecting a yarn for your project, it’s important to carefully consider these factors to ensure that you achieve the desired outcome.

In summary, when selecting the best yarn for crochet projects:

  • Choose the appropriate yarn weight based on your project requirements.
  • Select a fiber content that meets your needs in terms of durability and appearance.
  • Pick an appropriate hook size based on your chosen yarn weight.
  • Consider other factors such as color and texture preferences, as well as price point and care instructions.

If you’re looking for more inspiration or advice on selecting the perfect crochet yarns for your next project, visit our Easy Yarn Guide and Recommendations at

I wish you the best of luck on your crochet journey and hope that you find the perfect yarn for your next project.

If you’re currently on the lookout for your next crochet adventure, I would like to invite you to check out my 5-Star rated pattern shop.  Shop Patterns Here →

With step-by-step photos and a 100% satisfaction guarantee, I am confident that you will find a pattern that speaks to your creative soul.

Let me know in the comments what your favorite yarn so far is or one you’re excited to try!

Happy Hooking! 🧶


Share the Post:

Related Posts